‘Charming couple’ turn out to be the tenants from hell

Reprinted from Times Live, by Bobby Jordan – 2020-12-13

This house in Lochner Road, Constantia, in Cape Town has been taken over by hijackers. Attempts to get the illegal tenants evicted have been unsuccessful.

This house in Lochner Road, Constantia, in Cape Town has been taken over by hijackers. Attempts to get the illegal tenants evicted have been unsuccessful. Image: Esa Alexander


Catherine Deare thought she’d found the ideal tenants — a charming couple, full of smiles. Then they stopped paying rent, wouldn’t move out, and began making home improvements.

Two years after the couple moved into the R5m house in Constantia, Cape Town, Deare was forced to sell the property for less than half its value. She still owes the bank millions and is bankrupt.

Now the new owner has inherited the problem. The house and its leafy 937m² plot remain “hijacked”, by a new set of uninvited guests, several of them noisy and aggressive towards neighbours.

Earlier this month, police arrested one of them, allegedly for business robbery. But still the property goes from bad to worse, a blot in a suburb of wealthy homes.

The bond never materialised. Deare became embroiled in a standoff involving lawyers, police, private security guards and the Cape Town high court.

Her tenants obtained a court order against her for not returning their deposit, even though they had an unpaid utilities bill for twice the amount and had allegedly damaged the house.

She confronted them on the property to demand the keys, but a group of “threatening looking” people arrived in a flashy car and demanded she produce the deposit. “I thought I was going to be shot,” she said.

Faced with a lengthy court eviction battle, Deare said she had to concede defeat. “I eventually ran out of money.”

The house was given back to the bank and sold for R1.9m to a property investment company, which, a year later, is still battling to evict the tenants. The company’s lawyer, Wayne Hufkie, this week said there had been delays in obtaining a court order because the occupants refuse to be served a summons.

The sheriff broke down the fence to serve documents and the matter is to be heard in court next month.

“We’ve sent the sheriff out there two or three times,” said Hufkie. “To evict anybody you must have a court order. But in this matter, each time the occupancy keeps changing.”

The City of Cape Town problem building unit can’t get into the house. The “illegal occupants” refused officials entry to inspect, said the council’s head of safety and security Richard Bosman.

The city council has about 500 problem buildings, of which between 30% and 40% are illegally occupied.

There was no reply when the Sunday Times visited the Constantia property in Lochner Road.

The lawn was overgrown and an abandoned shopping trolley lay in the garden.

Neighbours said they had noticed “trolley squatters” who went on forays into the neighbourhood.

One neighbour criticised the council’s inaction: “How does the city justify the affected neighbours being charged full rates when everyone knows we will not get a market-related price with a hijacked property next door?”

Documents seen by the Sunday Times include an unpaid utilities bill for of R55,375 and e-mails from the illegal tenants, who could not be reached.

Property sources said house hijackers were exploiting the Prevention of Illegal Eviction from and Unlawful Occupation of Land (PIE) Act, which protects vulnerable families.

Links added by SD Law

If you need help with illegal tenants

This is an extreme case and, thankfully, rare. While rental housing legislation provides ample protection for tenants, to ensure the abuses of the past cannot be repeated, this article demonstrates that property owners also are entitled to the enjoyment of their property, and should not have their rights abused in this manner. We hope that the City of Cape Town can resolve this unpleasant situation swiftly.

Simon Dippenaar & Associates, Inc. is a specialist Cape Town law firm of eviction lawyers, now also operating in Johannesburg and Durban, helping both landlords and tenants with the eviction process. Contact one of our attorneys on 0860995146 or sdippenaar@sdlaw.co.za if you have concerns about your tenant/landlord relationship.

Further reading:


The information on this website is provided to assist the reader with a general understanding of the law. While we believe the information to be factually accurate, and have taken care in our preparation of these pages, these articles cannot and do not take individual circumstances into account and are not a substitute for personal legal advice. If you have a legal matter that concerns you, please consult a qualified attorney. Simon Dippenaar & Associates takes no responsibility for any action you may take as a result of reading the information contained herein (or the consequences thereof), in the absence of professional legal advice.